An EL teacher engages a first-grade student in a conversation about a story following a whole-class read-aloud.
Teacher: What was your favorite part of the story?
Student: Bear! Bear say, "I not scared, you scared!"
Teacher: When Bear is feeling scared, he says, "I'm not scared, you're scared!"
Student: (laughing) Bear scared of everything!
Teacher: Let's look at this illustration. What is Bear scared of here?
Student: The bridge. Look! It is old. Bear scared to fall in.
Teacher: I would be scared just like Bear! Bear doesn't want to fall through the old, rickety bridge.
Student: I scare too! But look here! (points to the illustration) Bear save Rabbit from falling.
Teacher: Yes! Bear saved Rabbit when the bridge broke. Bear was scared, but he saved Rabbit.
The student's oral language production is most consistent with which stage of English proficiency?